
Let me preface this post by saying that both of these blog tools have served me well in the past. When I first began using Wordpress on my hosted server I found w. Bloggar to be the best tool available for me to use: It was fast as hell, advanced, and did a great job. Then came Windows Live Writer (which I have previously posted about) and I switched to this. Lately I have been going back and forth using both since w. Bloggar had an update last month, but it’s time to choose. Hopefully my fellow bloggers can learn a few things as to maybe which blog tool would serve them best.
I won’t be covering installation and setup as they are both equally simple. I’ll be covering options and tools which I use most often (and I see others using most often), such as general formatting of posts, editing of previous posts, drafts for later publishing, inserting media such as screenshots, images, videos, and photos, and using features such as categories, tagging, etc. I’ll also be covering some annoyances I find in blogging tools and how both of these apps stand up.
Layout

As said above, w. Bloggar is fast as hell. Its layout is simple (but then again I’m using Windows Vista, so anything can seem simple if it’s not transparent and shiny). It’s layout is also pretty advanced in terms of functionality, putting many options at your fingertips. Any text formatting (bold, italic, strike), inserting (links, photo links, uploads) and coding needs (Javascript, code commenting, HTML code insertion) is all immediately available for your mouse to click on it.

Windows Live Writer’s layout is very simple and direct, with everything you need right up front as well. The sidebar holds information on your blog (in my case Wordpress) and links to the Dashboard and main site. Underneath it are sections containing your drafts, previous posts, and commands to insert items into the post you’re working on. The user interface blends well with Vista (it matches the rest of the Live family), and you can even change the colors of the menu interface to match your specific desktop theme.

Composing a Post
Composing your post in w. Bloggar is fairly simple, but I will say that you have to know at least some basic HTML to be on top of what’s going on. Any formatting that is controlled by HTML on your blog shows its code in the main window of w. Bloggar. For example, a link in your post will not appear as linked text, it will show all of the code.

All commands are executed with a button on the menu bar (or you can enter the code yourself), but either way the code is displayed. This is not to say that you only have to look at your post littered with HTML code. There is also a Preview tab in the main window that you can use to view it as it looks without the code. It’s important to note that this is not true WYSIWYG due to not being able to edit in the preview tab.

Live Writer gives you a WYSIWYG editor, letting you compose and edit your post using a word processor approach. You don’t see your HTML code as you format your writing, and it even offers you the option of downloading your site’s template to view how it will look after you post it.

Inserting Media
Inserting media into your post is easy with w. Bloggar, although there are some extra steps involved for inserting images. To insert an image file into your post you can choose one of two ways: (1) insert the code for an image already on the web, or (2) upload the image from w. Bloggar and choosing to insert it into the current post. While uploading the file then inserting it may not seem like a huge deal, it can only be done one at a time.

To insert media like YouTube (or other) videos all you have to do in w. Bloggar is choose Insert HTML Code, then paste the code from the media’s web site.
Live Writer, in a lot of ways, was made for bloggers who use a lot of media in their posts. In fact, it has an entire Insert menu on the sidebar where you can choose to insert any number of things.

When you insert photos into a post you choose them from your local hard drive and when you publish the post it automatically uploads them for you. With its video insertion menu you can type the URL of YouTube videos and it will post them, as well as other video providers. If you have a Soapbox account you can insert those videos. The Insert Website Image feature allows you to input a URL and Live Writer will grab a screenshot of it in your browser.
Other Features
Windows Live Writer allows you to postpone your posts depending on whether your blogging platform supports it, which makes it easy to keep a steady flow of posts on your blog by composing posts when you get those bursts of inspiration. w. Bloggar doesn’t support this.
Live Writer also allows you to post entries into multiple categories much easier than w. Bloggar, which allows you to post in one from the main window (to post to multiple categories you must open a menu and check the boxes for the categories you would like the post in).

Live Writer allows you to tag your posts for several social bookmarking platforms by default, and lets you add others to use in the future. In w. Bloggar you must use the standard insert HTML code feature. Live Writer also shows your previous posts in the sidebar, waiting to be edited when you realize you’ve messed up a link, fellow blogger’s name, or were just way too drunk to blog. Live Writer presents them visually in a WYSIWYG manner, whereas w. Bloggar shows them in robotic code view.

Windows Live Writer is also extensible, allowing you to install plugins which provide additional functionality. You can check out the entire gallery of plugins to see what kind of tools are open to you when you use Live Writer.
Conclusion
Both of these tools have their pros and cons, strengths and limitations. They both support a huge variety of blogging platforms such as Wordpress, Typepad, Blogger, Mambo, Drupal, and Live Spaces. They both provide most of the functionality a blogger would need from their go-to application, but one of them provides this functionality in a more straight forward and simpler fashion: Windows Live Writer. In my opinion, it doesn’t matter if you run XP or Vista, or what blogging platform you use (as long as it is a widely used one of course), Windows Live Writer would serve you well as your main blogging app.
What app do you use to post to your blog? Windows Live Writer? w. Bloggar? Ecto? Word? *shudder* Your blog’s administration interface? I’d like to know!
[Windows Live Writer] [w. Bloggar]